Discussion: Banning Books Silences Stories

Yesterday started Banned Books Week. It’s still hard for me to believe that today, in 2018, we’re still fighting for our right to read and for authors not to be silenced.

As I was thinking about this post to kick off Banned Books Week two recent hooplas came to mind.

  1. When Donald Trump filed suit to have Fire and Fury banned because it didn’t show him in a positive light
  2. The banning of To Kill a Mockingbird and The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn because of racial slurs

Maybe I’m being hyper sensitive because my parents didn’t censor my reading, but I find it an affront to my intelligence and I hate, absolutely hate, when my ability to make a simple decision, like whether to read something or not is taken away from me. Let me be the judge of what’s good for me to read.😡

What Do You Think About Banning Books?
Do You Think Books Should Be Banned/Challenged?
Are There Any Books That Should Be Banned/Challenged?

This year’s Banned Books Week theme is: 👇👇

The Office for Intellectual Freedom (OIF) puts out a Top Ten List every year of the most frequently challenged books and it never ceases to amaze me the reasons behind the challenges.

Fun Fact: According to the OIF there may be as many 10,766 challenges every year. WTF?!

Here is an infographic from the American Library Association of The Top Ten books that were banned or challenged in 2017 and their reasons.

Fun Fact: On the OIF’s 2015 Top Ten Most Frequently Challenged Books, nine contained diverse content – people of color, LGBT people and/or people with disabilities.

Hmm, I wonder why? 🤔 Don’t marginalized readers deserve to see themselves represented in books too? Don’t we all deserve to see ourselves represented in books? What’s wrong with having a POC or and LGBTQ+ or disabled main character?

Every year I try to read a book or two for Banned Books Week and this year I’m being pretty aggressive. I was a little surprised that the only book I’d read was The Hate U Give and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. I’ve had And Tango Makes Three, The Kite Runner and To Kill a Mockingbird on my list for a few yeas.

I went to the library and checked out the following picture books because I had to see what the problem is.

I’m also going to try and read Huck Finn and I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings which are on my list to read this year.

I should be able to get it done after all I am on vacation this week and it’s going to be chilly and rainy for most of my vacation.

This post is brought to you as part of the 2018 Discussion Challenge.

13 thoughts on “Discussion: Banning Books Silences Stories

  1. Nicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction October 18, 2018 / 10:11 pm

    I think it’s so sad when books are banned because of LGBT or other marginalized voices.

    I will say that it’s easier said than done to monitor your kids’ books completely so that you can have conversations with them about anything that comes up—I’m pretty conscientious about this and I’m an avid reader, but even I have let a book or two slip by and found out about content later. Ideally, I would read ALL my kids’ books and help them process them, but that’s not actually going to happen. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Broken Spine October 19, 2018 / 5:48 pm

      I agree you can’t monitor everything they read and do. You just have to hope they make good choices and learn from the bad ones.

      I know once my mom gave me the green light on certain genres and themes, she didn’t monitor too much.

      People that are actively banning books because of LGBT issues and those that contain marginalized voices are afraid of something. Usually what they dont know or understand and aren’t willing to gain knowledge or understanding. IMHO


  2. Wendy @ Falconer's Library September 29, 2018 / 11:09 pm

    I have a LOT of opinions about censoring and banning books, and have written about six different blog posts on it during the past three Banned Book Weeks. As a middle school reading teacher, I 100% believe that parents have the right to regulate what their own children read, but have no business trying to regulate what other kids read. And as a professional, I’m not going to be bringing a book in which the KKK leader explains that blacks are sub-human, as a previous commenter suggested. I have a responsibility to do some gatekeeping around what is a good fit in my classroom. I do not have a single student who would benefit from a book like that. But I do have students who would benefit from every single book on that “Most Challenged” list. Don’t even get me started on the wickedness of challenging a book just because it includes GLBQT characters, and the message that sends to GLBQT students about their right to common human respect. I also get angry about would-be-book-banners who pull words or phrases out of context instead of reading the whole work and seeing what the overall message is.

    I hope you enjoy all of the books you chose to read! I think And Tango Makes Three is one of the cutest picture books ever!


  3. Suziey Bravo September 24, 2018 / 11:09 pm

    Hm. I grew up in a super strict and conservative household. My mom actually loathed the fact that I was such a bookworm (she still does btw lol). But with all that being said, my mom never once censored my reading. Not that I was reading anything bad. Still though. She trusted my judgment. I think if she had ever told me “don’t read that”, it would have only piqued my interest. I think at some point parents have to trust that they’ve raised good kids. P.S. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings is on my TBR!

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Broken Spine September 25, 2018 / 12:26 am

      Wow! That’s interesting that you’re mom didn’t/doesn’t like that you’re a bookworm and never censored you’re reading. It’s good that she didn’t censor it. I think you’re when parents censor reading it makes you want to read it more. But that’s with adults too. You tell they can’t do something and it makes them want to. And you’re right at some point we have to trust that we’ve given our mini mes the tools to make the right decisions and trust that they will. I’m looking forward to reading I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. It’s been on my TBR for a long time.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Suziey Bravo September 25, 2018 / 3:02 am

        I know. Sometimes I feel like my upbringing was one strange paradox. My music, my clothes, pretty much everything in my life was controlled by my mom. But not my books. I still find that weird. I like to think she trusted me enough to let me read what I wanted. Which is why I don’t believe in censorship. Let people read what they will. “Good”, “bad”, and in between.
        Omg I actually got a free copy of it from the library recently. So now it’s just staring at me. Waiting for me to read it haha. Someday. Soon!


  4. FictionFan September 24, 2018 / 8:32 pm

    I have mixed feelings about the subject. I’d certainly ban some books from schools, especially ones that glamorise violence or have excessive swearing or graphic sex scenes, or disgusting representations of minority characters, or vile unacceptable political opinions, such as anti-Semitic. For adults – libraries, etc – not so much, although obviously we do ban stuff all the time, like child porn, and rightly so. The real question is who decides what criteria should be used in reaching the decision what should be banned or restricted. I always think a blanket denial of the need to ban glosses over the really putrid, sickening stuff that’s available, especially in these days of self-publishing. Would I, as an example, want my mythical teenage son to be reading a book he got out of the school library written by a leading member of the KKK telling him why black people shouldn’t be considered fully human? No, quite frankly, I wouldn’t… and I wouldn’t want my taxes/school fees to have paid for the book either…

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Broken Spine September 25, 2018 / 12:55 am

      For me, I don’t want people outside of my immediate family telling me that something is inappropriate. What one person deems sexually explicit or violent or immoral may not fit into my construct and vice versa.

      I will disagree with you on banning books from schools and school curricula. I agree that careful insight needs to happen when including books as required reading

      I believe that there are some books out there that shouldn’t be in school curricula, but at the university level all bets are off. If a parent objects to a book they have every right to voice that objection to the teacher or school board, but I don’t think their objection should be forced on everyone. If a parent objects then the parent should offer a reading alternative for his/her child.

      I agree with you, I wouldn’t want my mythical child checking out that sort of book from the school library either; but I would also look at it a teaching opportunity – an opportunity to have a discussion with my son about why they felt that way and have him do some research on Black History to find positive African American figures that debunk that myth.

      Liked by 1 person

      • FictionFan September 25, 2018 / 5:26 pm

        Ah, if only all parents paid attention to what their children are reading, but sadly many of them have to rely on schools or libraries guiding them or they get no guidance at all, I’m afraid.

        Liked by 1 person

  5. Jessie September 24, 2018 / 7:10 pm

    I want to read I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings soon, so I look forward to hearing your thoughts on it. Enjoy your vacation time!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. trentpmcd September 24, 2018 / 5:45 pm

    I need to read more “banned” books. Of course I have read the classics. i agree, most of the time books are banned because of the diversity of people and ideas.

    You haven’t read To Kill a Mockingbird? One of the best books ever. Huck Finn is a great book too, mostly because the most important content is what you get from reading between the lines, not the actual words themselves.

    Liked by 1 person

    • The Broken Spine September 24, 2018 / 7:39 pm

      I always feel embarrassed admitting I have yet to read To Kill a Mockingbird. It’s been on my TBR for years. The messages in Huck Finn are definitely beneath the surface. It’s a shame folks can’t get past some words in order to get the deeper meaning.

      Liked by 1 person

🗣Confab Here!🗣

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.